Tradcat,
Most forgiving…… now thats a hard one. Lets see, I own a Misty Dawn, Vixen, Morningstar, Northstar and a Taipan.
I can honestly shoot them all about the same on average, BUT the morningstar and Taipan are definitely the two I can shoot good all the time, no matter what. Why? Im not sure really, maybe the arrows are tuned better for those two bows?
The morningstar and taipan "FEEL" more in tune with me for sure.
I really enjoy american semi-longbows, maybe the nostalgia, the look, not really sure but I love them, so in that right the Morningstar gets a lot of shooting in. BUT, if you take nostalgia out of the equation, and just look at overall accuracy, and shoot ability of a bow I don't see where you could get better than the Taipan. Now I don't own an Argos, Renaissance, or appollo though so who knows. But for the bows I do own, the Taipan seems to be the overall most accurate cant miss bow I own closely followed by the Morningstar. This years 3D tourneys will be shot using the Taipan. This includes local outdoor and indoor 3D, indoor 300, outdoor American Rounds and if I can swing it the IBO Worlds will be shot with the Taipan, this bow is just that "consistently accurate" for ME. It seems to shoot itself.
With all that said, I don't feel you can make a bad choice, and the Morningstar still gets lots and lots of shooting time, and is also my goto hunting rig.