I'm not taking Bear Archery's side on this matter, but I find it interesting how fast people jump on the bandwagon to bash Bear Archery today.
My point is, if you or I were to have an issue with a bow we received from Tall Tines or Schafer or Stalker or another custom bowyer, we would go to great links to resolve the matter in private without tossing our issues out there on a public forum.
I had a horrible experience with a custom bowyer several years ago and only myself, the bowyer and a few close friends know anything about it.
I'm sure Bear Archery will get this one right eventually. Neil Byce is a standup guy and he and others are working hard to keep a traditional archery line alive at Bear Archery in a high tech, 350 fps, parallel limb, profit driven corporate world.
I wouldn't be happy with the riser you received either, but at least in your case the "bowyer" made an attempt to make it right and will likely make another and another until you are satisfied. I was told by the "custom" bowyer I had a bad experience with, to live with it or sell it and get back in line for another. No thanks
It's not a Grayling versus Gainesville thing either. Quite a few bows were returned to Grayling back in the day. Fred Bear stood behind them then and Bear Archery and Escalade Sports stand behind them today. Bear bows are mass produced. That's just the way it is, and the way it has been since Bear Archery started using fiberglass on limbs around 1950. They aren't Custom bows and haven't been since Nels Grumley stood at a shaving horse in the 1940s.
Even though they are production bows they still aren't cheap and you should get a product you can be proud to own. Stick with it and I bet you'll get a good one. Bear will make it right.
DD