New Recurve Purchase, thoughts?

[Jaydub]

So I'm thinking about making a recurve order in the next few months and I'm curious if anyone has any suggestions.

I'm leaning toward a Blacktail Elite or a Blackwidow PSA takedown.  I already have a one piece Widow that I love, and I've never shot a Blacktail.  I'd like to get the bow with 2 sets of limbs, one for practicing form and the other for hunting.  My thoughts are 40lbs, and 50lbs (at 28", though I draw to 29).

What are your thoughts on the Blacktail Elite?
 
Have you had any grip problems?  Some people have mentioned some issues with the grip around their thumb.

Does anyone out there have 2 sets of limbs for practice and hunting?  Has that worked well for you?  

Does anyone have both a Blacktail and a Widow?  Do you have a preference?

Thanks!

[Mountain State Archer]

decisions decisions.....never shot a Blacktail, but have 2 PSA takedowns(40lb and 57lb) that are awesome. ..the 40lb Ironwood will really throw an arrow

good luck on a tough but fun decision

[Lordswarrior]

looks like you already have two bows in mind but i would throw in  a bezaleel cougar by andy mccoy. i have shot it compared to a lot of other bows ( including a few VERY popular ones ) and in my humble opinion it beat them all in price, quality, speed, and overall good looks. just a thought.
good luck and enjoy the process.

[TOEJAMMER]

I have a number of bows, Robertsons, Widows, Cascade, and a few others with two sets of limbs for the very reason you have in mind.  Ironically, I always seem to just shoot them with the one set of hunting weight limbs, all in 60 or 61# at 28*.  But at some point, the other sets which are between 53 and 57# will be the ones that will get the nod.  At 73 the 60 and 61 are beginning to feel like 60 and 61.  I do have one bow that I have hd for 30 years.  It,too, has two sets, 60 and 74#.  That one I put away so I don't hurt myself.

[scott brightman]

Buying a Blacktail Bow would be the best investment
you would ever make.I have one that I bought from norm back in 2007.Norm will custom make your bow at your draw length and at your poundage. When I ordered my bow I told norm that I wanted my bow at 52#@25 inch draw and he nailed it. As for the grip,
I have had no problem. I did swap out my bowstring
to silent but deadly custom bowstring. Reseason is to get 2fps faster. Any questions,please feel free to PM me

[McDave]

While it seems logically that having two sets of limbs would give you the benefits of two bows at a lower cost, my experience is that I only end up using one set of limbs, so I end up with one bow at a higher cost    :confused:

Usually the bow is optimized for a particular purpose: hunting, target, etc., and those are the limbs that end up being used.  Maybe your experience will be different, but you asked the question.

[Jim Jackson]

I second McDave's thoughts.  2 limbs initially sounds like an economical solution, right up to the point where you realize that one set is always on the shelf and is never used. I did that with a recurve early on and ended up selling the second set of limbs because I just never used them the way I thought I would.

Another manufacturer to consider is Bill Dunn's Zipper bows.  I've shot a Blacktail and a Blackwidow and the Zipper is the more pointable, quiet, and solid bow in my opinion.  Nothing against the others, just my personal experience.

[David Mitchell]

I third McDave's thoughts. That has also been my experience.

[KAZ]

Cannot go wrong with a Black Widow PSA... I agree w/McDave. If it's for target/practice/form shooting I'd be looking to have a complete second bow. If I were looking to make a trip and save space/weight, one riser & two sets of limbs may be more beneficial... Not trying to discourage you, a second bow just gets shot/used far more than the second set of limbs.

[Jaydub]

I can certainly see myself not changing the limbs very often, so, thanks for saving me 600 bucks.  In that case I think I'll get a one piece.  I've heard of zipper, I'll do a little research on those.

[Benjy]

I love my Zippers! There is one on the St Judes auction Right now! You should check it out.

Benjy

[TaterHill Archer]

Never handled a Widow I didn't like.  I've had 2 PSA's and 2 PCH's.  All great bows.  I've had 2 Blacktails.  I wish I would have kept them. Blacktails are great shooters and one of the best looking bows on the market, in my opinion.

[**DONOTDELETE**]

ooops!  i double posted here... lets try again...

[**DONOTDELETE**]

If you are looking for something custom built to fit your hand and shooting style. You might want to check out my web site while you are shopping.

Here's a Sasquatch SS i just sent to France....This one has a full overlay riser with blind limb mounts to give it the one piece look, that you can still take down to travel with.

   

   

   

 

[nineworlds9]

Wow nice one Kirk!

[Archie]

I'm a big fan of Widows, and having shot and owned a number of different brands, I think of my 2 Widows (PMA, PLX) as the king and queen of bows.  I have heard nothing but excellent things of Blacktails, though.  Have you considered a Bob Lee recurve?  I had one on loan for several months and was really impressed with it.

[David Mitchell]

Kirk, I love that TD method.  Beautiful bow.

[D. Key]

I've owned both and they are both shooters for sure.  The only drawback on the Blacktail is the build time.  Last I heard it was about a year to have it built whereas, the Widow can be built within a couple of months.  Best of luck.

[old_goat2]

I echo the comments about two sets of limbs making a bow more expensive since you end up only using one set of the limbs.  If I had the extra coin laying around to have a custom bow made, Kirks Bigfoot Flatliner is at the top of my short list of bows I want to try followed by South Cox's Stalker Stickbows. Out of your list I would go with a Blacktail.

[jackdaw]

I really love those Blacktail bows.. Really love the Widows too..!! Tough call? I think if I had to pick I would go with the blacktail..... beautiful and fast..