Craftsmanship is ace. The 2010 Coffey-made one I had was a great shooting shorter bow. I have had a few short longbows since then that were either a little quicker or a little more dead in the hand, or a little quieter, but overall it was a very handy design that had a lot of thought put in. I'm about to take delivery of the St. Jude's Java Man bow, a 56" Elkheart, and Gregg explained to me that it is even more refined and better than what he was putting out back when he made the '10 bow I had- I'm pretty excited and can't wait to try it.
I haven't had the pleasure of a new Chuck Deschler made Shrew yet, but judging by Chuck's reputation I can't imagine that they are not great bows. It's my understanding that Chuck took the Shrew specs and redesigned the bow from the ground up according to his know-how and didn't just clone the bows Gregg was making. I'm told the new Shrews have very slightly larger risers and the limb dimensions are a little different as well. I'd love to try one someday,