Hello, Scooter:
Congrat's on the BW.
Went through the same thing when my first BW was delivered. Found that nothing was wrong. Called BW and was told by Roger that their limb bolt torque is between 65 and 70 INCH, AGAIN INCH, NOT FOOT, pounds. Torque values VARY with thread lubrication, sealing material and contamination (dirt). Less torque if lubed or sealed especially with TEFLON pipe thread tape. I strongly suggest you avoid any lube or sealing on the brass bolts. They won't rust.
You can clean the bolt threads with cotton patching using your fingernail to get into the threads. Then redo with a dry patch. Next carefully clean the threads in the riser with a lightly oiled Q-tip. Redo with a dry one to remove the oil.
To achieve the torque setting, affix a limb and press it firmly onto the stud. The o-ring is a moisture seal and will compress. Next run in the limb bolt using the LONG end of the Allen key until you just feel solid contact. Then reverse the Allen key to place the short end in the bolt. Tighten the bolt with the LONG end in your fingers ANOTHER 3 1/2 visual "clock hours" for the practical equivalent to 65 INCH pounds. 70 INCH pounds is 4 clock hours. 70' ok, too, so don't be concerned. The bolts and inserts will handle more torque but don't go there! This visual clock hours technique is used all over the mechanical realm and will be close enough and is an easy way to eliminate carrying more tools.
For what it may be worth, a BW pamphlet of instructions and a separate DVD came with your bow. The DVD is also viewable on UTUBE.
I have placed limb bolt index marks on all my trad, compound and cross bows for years. I use a narrow swipe of white correction fluid across the bolt face and bezel shoulder. Nail polish works, too. NONE have ever rotated. Of course there is the extremely remote chance that the female thread insert is loose, but I've never seen or heard of that. Index marks will put your mind to rest. BW loves to hear from its customers. Give em a call. Oops, it's the beginning of the season, so please be patient. They always return calls so leave your name and number.
Regards,
Kevin