Fellas,
i am always amazed at the variety of answers you from the 'gang.
I have used a bigjims before and i don't know if it was defected or what, but I did not like it. moved some, etc.
Had a Great Northern that i didn't like how the 4th and 5th arrow went in, i preferred the arrows all in a line. I don't like the idea of having to slide a broadhead tipped arrow so close to my string to put it in the quiver.
I have never used a selway slide on, but i think that is what I may need to try.