I'd be looking at Kustom King and/or RMSG.
In fact, I DO look at those gloves a lot. So far I have a Damascus, a deerskin "classic" (my first glove, think it was Kustom King's), and an American Leathers Full Shot.
Each are different - I mostly shoot the Damascus (just a bit thin though) for best feel, and the Full Shot for comfort and a bit more protection. I removed the fingertip pad insert in the Full Shot, which gives me more "feel", with plenty of protection.
Back to the deerskin: I think one of the Bearpaw's would be an excellent balance of qualities.