My old Shrew Clssic Hunter (51# @28") liked Carbon Express 150 with brass 50 or 100 grn inserts depending on broadhead weight. About 29" long. I think my nock height was about 5/8".
Then I called Ron LaClair from Shrew Bows and things got easier. He suggested 62-64 # spine Sitka Spruce , (Paul Jalon arrows) and they shot beautifully with 160 grn STOS. No worries about what weight insert, etc. - it was just fun to go out and shoot them. I am not recommending this for your bow necessarily, but more so that someone like Ron or Snag from Widernesd Custom Arrows could help you a lot selecting the right spine.
Good luck and keep after it, it will come together.
Something I read today in the archives of Tradgang may be worth mentioning:
Form trumps everything.