I would use a frame pack and quarter it and pack it out. From what I've found this is legal to do in Ohio, you have to call in your deer first and have the tag number they give you before cutting up the deer. Once you have the number they supply you with you do not have to leave the sex organ attached to anything like in some other states. The E-mail I read was from an ODNR officer, she said as long as the scraps are left where the deer died and not at a parking lot that you would be fine. Here's the E-mail
Thank you for your e-mail.
This is a new issue for the agency to deal with.
A deer may be quartered once it is permanently checked in. In previous
years a deer had to be taken whole with the head attached to a check
station, but that is no longer the case and deer can be checked over the
telephone. Once checked it, a deer may be handled in whatever way the
hunter wants.
Going from a strict interpretation of the law, it is not illegal to
leave the material from field dressing or quartering a deer at the place
it fell on a wildlife area.
The law states: "No person shall place or dispose of in any manner,...
anything ... of an unsightly or unsanitary nature on any state owned,
controlled, or administered land,..." While it may not be very clear,
the key words are "place or dispose of" mean that you cannot take the
material off-site and then bring it back and dump it. The other words
to look at are unsightly or unsanitary. In the woods, it is a normal
thing to find dead deer or other wild animals occasionally and is not
really thought of as unsightly or unsanitary. At the parking lot, it is
not normal, and could fit the terms unsightly or unsanitary.
If you quarter a deer at the place it fell, and leave the scraps etc. at
the site, it is not a problem under the current law. If it is done at
the parking lot or away from the hunting area and the material is
brought back, it is likely to result in a ticket.
State parks and other public areas not operated by ODNR Division of
Wildlife may have different rules.
If you have further questions or concerns, please contact us at
1-800-WILDLIFE.
Laura Roth
Division of Wildlife