I think Ive had most all of them and I have to say nothing beats a Rinehart.
The reality is, by nature of the broahead, anything BUT a pile of sand, is going to eventually get cut to chunks.....unfortunately with the price of targets, this is unavoidable. The Rineharts, despite getting cut up pretty darn good, still manage to stop the arrow nicely. I have a Rinehart "18 in 1" that Ive been sending broadheads into for over 3 years now and Im still very impressed with how that type of foam they use, stops the arrows. Being a target that really is like 18 targets in one, you have many angles to shoot at to prolong the targets life or should I say you having to get another target because you can see thru a hole in the middle. If I want my moneys worth, I buy Rineharts.