I both gun and bow hunt. I need meat for the family and time in the woods for my soul. For what it's worth I traded my compounds in for a matches pair of knives to match my longbow and I've sold all but one of my guns. I only need one gun as a guy that's primarily a bow hunter and if I'm going back to the bow the longbow is much more enjoyable for me.
I bow hunt HARD in the early pre-gun season to take in any meat that I can. IF I am comfortable with that, then I bow hunt the rest of the year but typically I am not good to keep the rifle locked away. Opening weekend of modern gun, I put the bow down while in the woods for deer until I get my meat quota that's needed for the freezer. Sometimes that takes more tags than others, depending on the sizes of the deer but meat hunting with a gun for me is not selective at all. If it's legal and brown, it's down and in the cooler. As soon as I have the meat that I need, the gun gets squeaky clean and locked away for the rest of the year. When bow hunting after I have all the meat that's NEEDED, I start becoming very selective with which animals I take and I concentrate on only mature bucks/does. Again, this is because they are harder to HUNT and I like the chase way much more than the kill. If/when I take more meat that I need for the family, I start sharing with co-workers or donate it to homeless shelters/soup kitchens/charity drives. No meat ever goes to waste.
I truly enjoy the HUNT better with a longbow. However, I need to bring home meat too and a gun is a superior tool to do so with so I continue to gun hunt as needed and I call that "meat insurance" or "grocery shopping."
I've gone some years without a single bow kill and I've gone some years without the need for a gun at all. To me the gun is a wonderful tool to improve the odds of feeding the family. The bow is a wonderful tool to improve the experience of going afield and immersing yourself in God's country while hopefully bringing home meat as well. They are two different tools for two different purposes in my opinion and BOTH are equally as valuable in my household.